How the simulation works
The game runs a teaching model of an open-cut iron ore mine, one day at a time, for 120 days. This page sets out what happens in a day, where the luck comes from, what everything costs, how the two reports are read and what each round changes. Every run in the game is worked out by this simulation, which runs on Stratflow's server. The money is set at the level of a small Western Australian iron ore producer. The numbers are not those of any particular operation.
The mine
Six stations stand in a line, and every tonne passes through all six in order. Each station's number is its nameplate: what it handles on an average day when it is running, in thousands of tonnes (kt).
| Station | What it stands for | Nameplate, mine as it stood |
|---|---|---|
| Prepare and stake | Clearing and surveying the ground and marking out blocks for the drills | 16 kt a day |
| Drill and blast | The drill rigs and the shot | 15 kt a day |
| Load and haul | The loader and the trucks, run as one station. It moves what the slower of the two fleets can | 14 kt a day |
| Crush | The primary crusher | 13 kt a day |
| Screening plant | The plant. In the first mine it stays at 10 kt a day in every round: a second plant is capital the board has not approved | 10 kt a day |
| Rail load-out | Loading the product onto trains | 12 kt a day |
Between each pair of stations is a place where stock can be held: staked blocks (ore marked out for the drills and still in the ground), blasted ore on the pit floor, the finger stockpile in front of the crusher, the primary stockpile that feeds the plant, and the product stockpile behind the plant. In the mine as it stood none of the five has any room, so each station is tied to the next. Every stock place starts a run empty, except in Round 5.
A day
Each station's rate for the day. A station's rate on a given day is its nameplate times a factor drawn evenly between 80 and 120 per cent. The screening plant is a steadier machine: 90 to 110 per cent.
Stoppages. Each station is up 90 per cent of the time. On about one day in five a stoppage strikes it, and the stoppage takes an evenly spread share of that day, anything from a few minutes to the whole day. Over a run that averages one tenth of the time. A station with its spares and a fitter on hand is up 95 per cent of the time: a stoppage on about one day in ten. Stoppages strike each station on its own.
How the ore moves. Ore passes through the whole chain within the day. Each station works on what the station before it delivered that day plus what is in the stock place in front of it, up to what it can do that day, stoppages counted. It can put out only what the next station takes that day plus the room left in the stock place after it. A station that has nothing to work on stands, and so does one that has nowhere to put its output. A stoppage at one station therefore reaches its neighbours the same day, unless stock in front of them or room behind them takes up the slack.
An example. Say the crusher can do 13 kt today, load and haul delivers 9 kt and the finger stockpile in front of the crusher holds 2 kt. The crusher does 11 kt and empties the finger stockpile. If the primary stockpile after it is full and the screening plant can take only 8 kt today, the crusher can put out no more than 8 kt, and it is blocked for the rest of its day.
What a station's day is called. Starved: ore ran short, so it did less than 98 per cent of what it could. Blocked: it ran out of room for its output. Stopped: it did all it could in the time it had, but a stoppage took a tenth of its day or more. Running: none of these. Each day gets one name, so a station that lost part of its day to a stoppage and also ran short of ore is counted as starved.
The pace-setter. Each day the model works out which station set the pace of the screening plant's tonnes. If the plant did all it could, it set the pace itself. If it was short of ore, the model walks back up the chain to the first station that did all it could that day, stoppages counted. If it was blocked, it walks down the chain. A stoppage that stock covered does not count, because the plant never felt it. A station counts as a pace-setter of a run when it set the pace on at least 8 of the 120 days.
Stock. At the end of each day a stock place holds what it held, plus what came in, less what went out, up to its room. Stock in front of the station the mine is run around shows green at two-thirds full or more, yellow from a third, and red below that. Room after that station reads the other way round, because there it is the empty space that protects it. In the mine as it stood, that station is the plant. A place with no stock is marked "No stock" in the drawing of the mine, or "No room" after that station. The mine as it stood has no stock anywhere.
The board. The drawing of the mine also tells the run so far. A bar on each station shows where its capacity went over the days played: of what it could have done with no stoppage, the share it moved, the share its own stoppages took, and the shares it could have handled and did not while it stood starved or blocked. Under the drawing each station has a row with one mark for every day: at its full rate, held by its own stoppage, starved or blocked, with a dark foot under the station that set the pace that day. A station's states have colours of their own, blue, grey and two purples. Green, yellow and red are kept for the level of a stock place and for a day against the reference level, and a key sits beside each. Each stock place is drawn against the most room the game offers there, with the room the mine has boxed in, its level through the run, and the days it stood empty and full. Where a round changes a station's number, the earlier number is struck through beside the new one, with a few words on what changed it, and the Round 1 mine's own finished run stands above. The days can be paused, stepped one at a time or skipped, and a run stops on one or two days to say in a sentence what happened on them.
The four figures. At the head of every run, above the drawing, stand its tonnes shipped a day, its unit cost, its operating cost a day and its profit over the 120 days. They are filled in when the days end. From Round 2 on, the change from Round 1 on the same days is in bold under each, in per cent for the first three and in dollars for profit, with the Round 1 figure beneath. In Round 7 the change is from the mine before the review.
The luck
Each station's rate factor and its stoppage for each day come from a luck code. The standard code is 4189 in the first mine and 8710 in the second, and a player can choose another. A different code is a different 120 days.
The draws do not depend on the design: each station gets the same draw on the same day, whatever the player has done. A station with better availability shakes off part or all of a stoppage that would strike it at 90 per cent, and that difference is the design's doing. So when two results on the same code differ, the difference comes from the mines and not from the luck. The two mines use a code differently, so one code gives different days in each. In Round 4 the load-out's draws decide which train slots are lost and which extra slots are offered.
One run can flatter a design, so the game also runs mines on other sets of days. The test on 300 other lucks runs a mine on 300 other codes and reports the average. The range charts in Round 4 and the debrief draw the same 300 runs: each line runs from the result reached in nine runs out of ten to the result reached in one run out of ten, with the middle run as a dot. Round 6 runs 150 sets of 120 days at each level of availability.
The money
| Item | Amount | How it is charged |
|---|---|---|
| Ore shipped | $100 a tonne | Paid on what the load-out ships, at the port. Cargo on an extra train slot in Round 4 sells at 85 per cent of the price. |
| Capacity | $8k a day for each kt a day of nameplate | At every station, whether the capacity is used or not. The mine as it stood has 80 kt a day of nameplate: $640k a day, which is its budget. |
| Room for stock | $8k a day for each 10 kt of room | Whether the room holds ore or not. It stands for the pad and the gear that rehandles the ore. In the second mine, room in the pit costs nothing. |
| Interest on stock | 10 per cent a year | Charged each day on the ore held at the end of the day, valued at $100 a tonne. Ore still in the ground (staked blocks, and drilled holes in the second mine) carries none. |
| Relief crew | $8k a day | At the station the mine is run around. It keeps the station working through meal breaks and shift change: 10 per cent more rate. |
| Spares and a fitter | $8k a day | At the same station. Its availability is 95 per cent instead of 90. |
| Product beds, Round 4 | $10.4k a day each | Each bed is 13 kt of room, one train. |
| Overflow pad, Round 4 | $4 a tonne each way | No room charge. Every tonne moved to the pad is handled out and back. |
The charges for capacity, room, relief crews and spares are fixed by the day: they do not fall when a station stands. Profit is sales less cost over the run, and unit cost is cost over the tonnes shipped. Product left on the beds or the pad at the end of Round 4 is counted at the sale price. The board's budget for the first mine is $640k a day, and in Round 2 it wants $120k a day out of it. For the second mine those figures are $616k and $80k.
The two reports
Every run is read two ways, on the same days.
The cost report is what the monthly pack shows: operating cost a day against the budget, unit cost against the budget spread over the tonnes the plan assumes, the capacity paid for and not used, how much of its nameplate each station handled, and the stock held and what it cost.
The flow report is what the ops room watches: tonnes shipped against the reference level, the stock in front of the plant and the room behind it (in days of plant feed), the days the plant was starved, blocked or stopped, the stations that set the pace, and the best-day gap.
The reference level follows the TOC Flow Room visibility template. It is the daily average the mine is asked for, set at 85 per cent of what the station the mine is run around can average with all its stoppages counted. For the mine as it stood that is 85 per cent of 9 kt a day (10 kt at 90 per cent availability): 7.65 kt a day. A day below the reference level is red. A day 18 per cent or more above it is green, the catch-up level. Yellow lies between. Every other station is shown with the load that level puts on it, which should be no more than 75 per cent of what it can average.
The best-day gap sets the plant's three best days against its daily average: the gap between them, as a share of the best days. The Best-Day Diagnostic reads the same gap on the tonnes a real plant takes each day, and reads 25 per cent or more as the mark of a balanced-capacity chain.
What each round changes
In the first mine, "Mining with expensive plant":
| Round | What the simulation does |
|---|---|
| 1. Predict | Runs the mine as it stood, after the player predicts what it will ship a day. |
| 2. Cost world | Runs the mine with the savings the player takes. Park three trucks: load and haul 14 to 11 kt a day ($24k). Right-size four stations to just above the plant ($88k). A leaner blast pattern: the loader digs at 70 per cent of its rate and load and haul loses 5 points of availability ($16k). Drop the relief operators at the plant: 90 per cent of its rate ($8k). Defer planned maintenance: 5 points of availability at every station ($32k). Move the plant's spares to the central store: 5 points at the plant ($8k). In a room each department gets its own two savings, twelve in all, with its own share of the target. |
| 3. Flow | Runs the player's design: the station the mine is run around, the nameplate of every station but the plant (8 to 18 kt a day), the stock at each place (0, 10, 20 or 30 kt, or a third of the reference stock there: 3 kt, or 7 kt at the finger and primary stockpiles), and a relief crew and spares at the named station. "Load a reference design" loads the low-stock reference: every station but the plant at 14 kt a day, a relief crew and spares at the plant, and a third of the reference stock at every place (3 kt of staked blocks, 3 kt of blasted ore, 7 kt on the finger stockpile, 7 kt on the primary stockpile and 3 kt of product room). After it runs, the page offers to fill every place to the full reference stock (10, 10, 20, 20 and 10 kt) and run the same days again. Both steps set what the stock cost in room and interest beside the sales it brought in. Every attempt is set beside the mine as it stood and the low-stock reference. |
| 4. The rail | Runs the reference design (or the player's own best design, if they switch to it) with the stock after the plant laid out as product beds and trains on a timetable: one slot a day, six days a week, a full 13 kt train or none, about one slot in twelve lost to rail faults and track work, and on about one day in twelve another mine's slot offered. The player chooses the number of beds, whether to stop the plant or use the pad when the beds are full, and whether to take the extra slots. |
| 5. The ops room | Plays three weeks (21 days) on a fixed mine: 15, 15, 15, 15, 10 and 13 kt a day, starting with 14 kt on the primary stockpile and 3 kt of product. Its breakdowns are scripted and the same for every player, with no random stoppages. Every station's rate swings 90 to 110 per cent, no interest is charged, and product left on day 21 is counted at the sale price. Six calls come up. The round sets the player's calls beside the ops-room rules and the cost-report reflex on the same days. |
| 6. Fleet | Runs the mine as it stood, the Round 2 mine, the best Round 3 design and the low-stock reference at 100, 95, 90, 85 and 80 per cent availability, 150 runs of 120 days at each level. With no stoppages at all the low-stock reference makes more than the whole reference design ($51.05M against $46.45M), and at 80 per cent much less ($5.92M against $17.87M). |
| 7. Next manager | Hands every player the reference design with two beds, the pad and the extra slots, then runs it again with the finance review's savings the player keeps. |
| Debrief | Sets every way the player ran the mine on the same 300 other sets of days. In the first mine the chart starts from the low-stock reference and counts the runs in which each way made more than it. The first mine's debrief also runs the reference flow design on the game's own 120 days with no stock, a third of its stock and its full stock, and sets the room and interest the stock cost beside the sales the mine made. Tests four of Goldratt's statements on the player's own runs. Under one that did not hold, it runs the same test on a mine the statement is meant for: the mine as it stood for the first (when Round 2 was played), and the reference flow design for the other three (when the player's best design is another one). |
The second mine
"Mining not quite delivering" has the same six stations, with nameplates of 14, 11, 14, 13, 12 and 13 kt a day, and six stock places: staked blocks, drilled holes waiting for the blast, broken ore on the floor, then the finger, primary and product stockpiles.
Between drill and blast and load and haul sits the blast. On a blast day every drilled hole becomes broken ore, as far as the room for broken ore allows. A blast takes three hours from the drills and one hour from load and haul that day. Round 1 blasts every day; in Round 3 the player can blast every day, twice a week or once a week. Room in the pit (staked blocks, drilled holes and broken ore, up to 80 kt each) costs nothing, and the stockpiles cost what they cost in the first mine.
Its pace is read at the station that can average the least: the drills, in its Round 1 mine. A day the mine waited for the next blast counts for drill and blast.
In Round 3 the mine's own rigs stay at 11 kt a day, but a contractor's rig can be hired by the day: 2 kt a day more at drill and blast for $24k a day. With another station named, the rigs can keep their own hot-seat changes and their own spares and fitter, at $8k a day each. The plant there can be run at up to 14 kt a day. The second mine plays Rounds 1 to 3, then the ageing fleet as its Round 4, the debrief and the last step.
What the model leaves out
- Ore grade and product quality: every tonne is the same.
- A price that moves: ore is $100 a tonne throughout, except cargo on an extra train slot in Round 4, at $85.
- Royalties, freight and other charges by the tonne. The only one is the pad's handling in Round 4.
- Events that stop several stations at once, such as heavy rain. Stoppages strike each station on its own; the ops room's scripted breakdowns are the exception.
- Capital: capacity is paid for by the day, and no round buys a second plant.
Inspired by the Theory of Constraints dice game and real mining behaviours. The reference level and the stock colours follow the TOC Flow Room visibility template (v1.1, 2014). The four statements tested in the debrief are Eli Goldratt's.
